script-build-and-framework-tmp/script_build_host/tests/test_phase_two_inputs_validation.py

from __future__ import annotations

import hashlib
import json
from dataclasses import replace
from datetime import UTC, datetime
from types import SimpleNamespace

import pytest
from agent.orchestration import (
    AcceptanceCriterion,
    ArtifactRef,
    ArtifactSnapshot,
    AttemptStatus,
    DecisionAction,
    PlannerDecision,
    TaskAttempt,
    TaskLedger,
    TaskRecord,
    TaskSpec,
    TaskStatus,
    ValidationReport,
    ValidationRunStatus,
    ValidationVerdict,
)

from script_build_host.agents.validation import (
    ScriptBuildValidationPolicy,
    precheck_business_artifact,
    validate_phase_two_defects,
    validation_layer,
)
from script_build_host.application.phase_two_inputs import (
    AcceptedInputResolver,
    ActiveFrontierResolver,
    PhaseTwoInputError,
)
from script_build_host.domain.artifacts import (
    ArtifactKind,
    ArtifactState,
    ArtifactVersion,
    EvidenceRecordV1,
)
from script_build_host.domain.phase_two_artifacts import (
    CandidateLineageV1,
    ParagraphArtifactV1,
    ScriptParagraphV1,
)
from script_build_host.domain.task_contracts import (
    AcceptedDecisionRef,
    AcceptedInput,
    AcceptedInputBundleV1,
    ScriptCriterion,
    ScriptIntentClass,
    ScriptTaskBudget,
    ScriptTaskContractV1,
    ScriptTaskKind,
)
from script_build_host.infrastructure.canonical_json import canonical_sha256

DIGEST = "sha256:" + "a" * 64
SNAPSHOT_REF = "script-build://inputs/11"
SCOPE = "script-build://scopes/opening"
WRITE = "script-build://writes/paragraphs/1"


def _contract(
    *,
    kind: ScriptTaskKind = ScriptTaskKind.PARAGRAPH,
    scope: str = SCOPE,
    write_scope: tuple[str, ...] = (WRITE,),
    supersedes: tuple[str, ...] = (),
) -> ScriptTaskContractV1:
    schemas = {
        ScriptTaskKind.PARAGRAPH: "paragraph-artifact/v1",
        ScriptTaskKind.ELEMENT_SET: "element-set-artifact/v1",
        ScriptTaskKind.COMPARE: "comparison-artifact/v1",
        ScriptTaskKind.DECODE_RETRIEVAL: "evidence-record/v1",
    }
    return ScriptTaskContractV1(
        task_kind=kind,
        scope_ref=scope,
        intent_class=ScriptIntentClass.EXPLORE,
        objective="produce one independently verifiable increment",
        input_decision_refs=(),
        base_artifact_ref=None,
        write_scope=write_scope,
        gap_ref=None,
        output_schema=schemas[kind],
        criteria=(ScriptCriterion("closed", "candidate is concretely realized"),),
        budget=ScriptTaskBudget(),
        supersedes_decision_ids=supersedes,
    )


def _paragraph_artifact(*, text: str = "specific opening") -> ParagraphArtifactV1:
    return ParagraphArtifactV1(
        lineage=CandidateLineageV1(
            scope_ref=SCOPE,
            input_snapshot_ref=SNAPSHOT_REF,
            input_closure_digest=DIGEST,
            write_scope=(WRITE,),
        ),
        paragraphs=(
            ScriptParagraphV1(
                paragraph_id=1,
                paragraph_index=1,
                level=1,
                parent_id=None,
                name="opening",
                content_range={},
                description=text,
            ),
        ),
    )


def _task(task_id: str, *, parent: str | None, kind: str, status: TaskStatus) -> TaskRecord:
    return TaskRecord(
        task_id=task_id,
        goal_id=None,
        parent_task_id=parent,
        display_path=task_id,
        specs=[
            TaskSpec(
                version=1,
                objective="bounded increment",
                acceptance_criteria=(AcceptanceCriterion("closed", "closed"),),
                context_refs=(
                    f"script-build://task-kinds/{kind}",
                    SNAPSHOT_REF,
                ),
            )
        ],
        status=status,
    )


class _TaskStore:
    def __init__(self, ledger: TaskLedger) -> None:
        self.ledger = ledger

    async def load(self, root_trace_id: str) -> TaskLedger:
        assert root_trace_id == self.ledger.root_trace_id
        return self.ledger


class _SnapshotStore:
    def __init__(self, snapshot: ArtifactSnapshot) -> None:
        self.snapshot = snapshot

    async def get(self, root_trace_id: str, snapshot_id: str) -> ArtifactSnapshot:
        assert root_trace_id == "root"
        assert snapshot_id == self.snapshot.snapshot_id
        return self.snapshot


class _Artifacts:
    def __init__(self, version: ArtifactVersion) -> None:
        self.version = version

    async def read_by_ref(self, ref: ArtifactRef, **owners: object) -> ArtifactVersion:
        assert ref.digest == self.version.canonical_sha256
        assert owners == {
            "script_build_id": 7,
            "task_id": "child",
            "attempt_id": "attempt-child",
        }
        return self.version


class _Contracts:
    def __init__(self, values: dict[str, ScriptTaskContractV1]) -> None:
        self.values = values

    async def read_for_task(
        self, *, root_trace_id: str, task: TaskRecord, spec_version: int | None = None
    ) -> ScriptTaskContractV1:
        assert root_trace_id == "root"
        assert spec_version == 1
        return self.values[task.task_id]


def _closed_fixture() -> tuple[AcceptedInputResolver, TaskLedger, TaskAttempt]:
    root = _task("root-task", parent=None, kind="root", status=TaskStatus.NEEDS_REPLAN)
    parent = _task("parent", parent="root-task", kind="compose", status=TaskStatus.RUNNING)
    child = _task("child", parent="parent", kind="paragraph", status=TaskStatus.COMPLETED)
    parent.child_task_ids.append("child")
    root.child_task_ids.append("parent")
    ref = ArtifactRef(
        uri="script-build://artifact-versions/1",
        kind=ArtifactKind.PARAGRAPH.value,
        version="1",
        digest=DIGEST,
    )
    child_attempt = TaskAttempt(
        attempt_id="attempt-child",
        task_id="child",
        spec_version=1,
        worker_trace_id="worker",
        worker_preset="script_paragraph_worker",
        execution_mode="new",
        accepted_child_decision_ids=(),
        status=AttemptStatus.SUBMITTED,
        snapshot_id="artifact-snapshot",
        submission=SimpleNamespace(artifact_refs=[ref], evidence_refs=[]),
    )
    validation = ValidationReport(
        validation_id="validation-child",
        task_id="child",
        attempt_id="attempt-child",
        spec_version=1,
        snapshot_id="artifact-snapshot",
        validator_trace_id="validator",
        status=ValidationRunStatus.COMPLETED,
        verdict=ValidationVerdict.PASSED,
    )
    decision = PlannerDecision(
        decision_id="decision-child",
        task_id="child",
        action=DecisionAction.ACCEPT,
        reason="passed",
        from_status=TaskStatus.AWAITING_DECISION,
        to_status=TaskStatus.COMPLETED,
        attempt_id="attempt-child",
        validation_id="validation-child",
    )
    child.attempt_ids.append(child_attempt.attempt_id)
    child.validation_ids.append(validation.validation_id)
    child.decision_ids.append(decision.decision_id)
    parent_attempt = TaskAttempt(
        attempt_id="attempt-parent",
        task_id="parent",
        spec_version=1,
        worker_trace_id="compose-worker",
        worker_preset="script_compose_worker",
        execution_mode="new",
        accepted_child_decision_ids=(decision.decision_id,),
    )
    ledger = TaskLedger(
        root_trace_id="root",
        mission="mission",
        root_task_id="root-task",
        tasks={item.task_id: item for item in (root, parent, child)},
        attempts={
            child_attempt.attempt_id: child_attempt,
            parent_attempt.attempt_id: parent_attempt,
        },
        validations={validation.validation_id: validation},
        decisions={decision.decision_id: decision},
    )
    normalized = {
        "summary": "bounded",
        "artifact_refs": [
            {
                "uri": ref.uri,
                "kind": ref.kind,
                "version": ref.version,
                "digest": ref.digest,
                "summary": ref.summary,
                "metadata": ref.metadata,
            }
        ],
        "evidence_refs": [],
    }
    snapshot = ArtifactSnapshot(
        snapshot_id="artifact-snapshot",
        attempt_id=child_attempt.attempt_id,
        normalized_content=normalized,
        sha256=_snapshot_sha(normalized),
        artifact_refs=[ref],
        evidence_refs=[],
    )
    artifact = replace(_paragraph_artifact(), canonical_sha256=DIGEST)
    version = ArtifactVersion(
        artifact_version_id=1,
        script_build_id=7,
        task_id="child",
        attempt_id=child_attempt.attempt_id,
        spec_version=1,
        artifact_type=ArtifactKind.PARAGRAPH,
        canonical_sha256=DIGEST,
        state=ArtifactState.FROZEN,
        artifact=artifact,
        created_at=datetime.now(UTC),
        frozen_at=datetime.now(UTC),
    )
    resolver = AcceptedInputResolver(
        task_store=_TaskStore(ledger),
        artifact_store=_SnapshotStore(snapshot),
        artifacts=_Artifacts(version),
        contracts=_Contracts({"child": _contract(), "parent": _contract()}),
    )
    return resolver, ledger, parent_attempt


@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_accepted_input_closes_decision_validation_snapshot_and_artifact() -> None:
    resolver, _, attempt = _closed_fixture()
    bundle = await resolver.resolve(
        root_trace_id="root",
        script_build_id=7,
        task_id="parent",
        attempt_id=attempt.attempt_id,
        contract=_contract(),
        input_snapshot_id="11",
    )
    assert [item.decision_id for item in bundle.inputs] == ["decision-child"]
    assert bundle.inputs[0].source == "direct-child"
    assert bundle.input_closure_digest.startswith("sha256:")


@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_legacy_attempt_without_frozen_child_set_fails_closed() -> None:
    resolver, ledger, attempt = _closed_fixture()
    ledger.attempts[attempt.attempt_id] = replace(attempt, accepted_child_decision_ids=None)
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="CHILD_DECISION_INVALID"):
        await resolver.resolve(
            root_trace_id="root",
            script_build_id=7,
            task_id="parent",
            attempt_id=attempt.attempt_id,
            contract=_contract(),
            input_snapshot_id="11",
        )


@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_mid_retrieval_replacement_freezes_new_evidence_and_old_candidate() -> None:
    resolver, ledger, parent_attempt = _closed_fixture()
    old_ref = ledger.attempts["attempt-child"].submission.artifact_refs[0]
    old_contract = _contract()

    # The old accepted Paragraph remains a completed sibling.  The replacement
    # consumer gets new Evidence from its own direct Retrieval child and imports
    # the immutable old Decision explicitly; it never reads a mutable "latest".
    ledger.tasks["child"].parent_task_id = "root-task"
    ledger.tasks["root-task"].child_task_ids = ["child", "parent"]
    replacement_task = _task(
        "parent", parent="root-task", kind="paragraph", status=TaskStatus.RUNNING
    )
    replacement_task.child_task_ids = ["retrieval"]
    replacement_task.attempt_ids = [parent_attempt.attempt_id]
    ledger.tasks["parent"] = replacement_task

    retrieval = _task(
        "retrieval", parent="parent", kind="decode-retrieval", status=TaskStatus.COMPLETED
    )
    retrieval_ref = ArtifactRef(
        "script-build://artifact-versions/2",
        ArtifactKind.EVIDENCE.value,
        "2",
        DIGEST,
    )
    retrieval_attempt = TaskAttempt(
        attempt_id="attempt-retrieval",
        task_id="retrieval",
        spec_version=1,
        worker_trace_id="retrieval-worker",
        worker_preset="script_decode_retrieval_worker",
        execution_mode="new",
        accepted_child_decision_ids=(),
        status=AttemptStatus.SUBMITTED,
        snapshot_id="retrieval-snapshot",
        submission=SimpleNamespace(artifact_refs=[], evidence_refs=[retrieval_ref]),
    )
    retrieval_validation = ValidationReport(
        validation_id="validation-retrieval",
        task_id="retrieval",
        attempt_id=retrieval_attempt.attempt_id,
        spec_version=1,
        snapshot_id="retrieval-snapshot",
        validator_trace_id="retrieval-validator",
        status=ValidationRunStatus.COMPLETED,
        verdict=ValidationVerdict.PASSED,
    )
    retrieval_decision = PlannerDecision(
        decision_id="decision-retrieval",
        task_id="retrieval",
        action=DecisionAction.ACCEPT,
        reason="new evidence passed",
        from_status=TaskStatus.AWAITING_DECISION,
        to_status=TaskStatus.COMPLETED,
        attempt_id=retrieval_attempt.attempt_id,
        validation_id=retrieval_validation.validation_id,
    )
    retrieval.attempt_ids = [retrieval_attempt.attempt_id]
    retrieval.validation_ids = [retrieval_validation.validation_id]
    retrieval.decision_ids = [retrieval_decision.decision_id]
    ledger.tasks[retrieval.task_id] = retrieval
    ledger.attempts[retrieval_attempt.attempt_id] = retrieval_attempt
    ledger.validations[retrieval_validation.validation_id] = retrieval_validation
    ledger.decisions[retrieval_decision.decision_id] = retrieval_decision
    ledger.attempts[parent_attempt.attempt_id] = replace(
        parent_attempt,
        accepted_child_decision_ids=(retrieval_decision.decision_id,),
    )

    retrieval_normalized = {
        "summary": "bounded retrieval evidence",
        "artifact_refs": [],
        "evidence_refs": [
            {
                "uri": retrieval_ref.uri,
                "kind": retrieval_ref.kind,
                "version": retrieval_ref.version,
                "digest": retrieval_ref.digest,
                "summary": retrieval_ref.summary,
                "metadata": retrieval_ref.metadata,
            }
        ],
    }
    retrieval_snapshot = ArtifactSnapshot(
        snapshot_id="retrieval-snapshot",
        attempt_id=retrieval_attempt.attempt_id,
        normalized_content=retrieval_normalized,
        sha256=_snapshot_sha(retrieval_normalized),
        artifact_refs=[],
        evidence_refs=[retrieval_ref],
    )
    evidence = EvidenceRecordV1(
        evidence_id="mid-retrieval",
        source_type="decode",
        tool_name="retrieve_decode",
        query={"query": "opening detail", "top_k": 3},
        source_refs=("decode-index://fixture/new-evidence",),
        raw_artifact_ref=None,
        summary="One visible detail contradicts the original opening assumption.",
        supports=(SCOPE,),
        confidence="high",
        limitations=(),
        content_sha256=DIGEST,
        created_at=datetime.now(UTC),
    )
    evidence_version = ArtifactVersion(
        artifact_version_id=2,
        script_build_id=7,
        task_id="retrieval",
        attempt_id=retrieval_attempt.attempt_id,
        spec_version=1,
        artifact_type=ArtifactKind.EVIDENCE,
        canonical_sha256=DIGEST,
        state=ArtifactState.FROZEN,
        artifact=evidence,
        created_at=datetime.now(UTC),
        frozen_at=datetime.now(UTC),
    )

    old_snapshot = resolver._artifact_store.snapshot

    class SnapshotStore:
        async def get(self, root_trace_id: str, snapshot_id: str) -> ArtifactSnapshot:
            assert root_trace_id == "root"
            return {
                old_snapshot.snapshot_id: old_snapshot,
                retrieval_snapshot.snapshot_id: retrieval_snapshot,
            }[snapshot_id]

    old_version = resolver._artifacts.version

    class Artifacts:
        async def read_by_ref(self, ref: ArtifactRef, **owners: object) -> ArtifactVersion:
            version = {old_ref.uri: old_version, retrieval_ref.uri: evidence_version}[ref.uri]
            assert owners == {
                "script_build_id": 7,
                "task_id": version.task_id,
                "attempt_id": version.attempt_id,
            }
            return version

    replacement_contract = replace(
        old_contract,
        intent_class=ScriptIntentClass.REPLACE,
        input_decision_refs=(
            AcceptedDecisionRef(
                "decision-child",
                old_ref,
                SCOPE,
                ScriptTaskKind.PARAGRAPH,
            ),
        ),
        supersedes_decision_ids=("decision-child",),
    )
    resolver._artifact_store = SnapshotStore()
    resolver._artifacts = Artifacts()
    resolver._contracts.values = {
        "child": old_contract,
        "retrieval": replace(
            _contract(kind=ScriptTaskKind.DECODE_RETRIEVAL),
            write_scope=(),
        ),
        "parent": replacement_contract,
    }

    bundle = await resolver.resolve(
        root_trace_id="root",
        script_build_id=7,
        task_id="parent",
        attempt_id=parent_attempt.attempt_id,
        contract=replacement_contract,
        input_snapshot_id="11",
    )
    assert [item.decision_id for item in bundle.inputs] == [
        "decision-retrieval",
        "decision-child",
    ]
    assert [item.source for item in bundle.inputs] == ["direct-child", "explicit"]
    assert bundle.superseded_decision_ids == ("decision-child",)
    assert bundle.input_closure_digest.startswith("sha256:")


@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_direct_child_is_revalidated_against_consumer_scope_and_kind() -> None:
    resolver, _, attempt = _closed_fixture()
    resolver._contracts.values["parent"] = replace(
        _contract(), scope_ref="script-build://scopes/ending"
    )
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="INPUT_SCOPE_MISMATCH"):
        await resolver.resolve(
            root_trace_id="root",
            script_build_id=7,
            task_id="parent",
            attempt_id=attempt.attempt_id,
            contract=resolver._contracts.values["parent"],
            input_snapshot_id="11",
        )

    resolver, _, attempt = _closed_fixture()
    consumer = replace(
        _contract(),
        task_kind=ScriptTaskKind.CANDIDATE_PORTFOLIO,
        intent_class=ScriptIntentClass.PORTFOLIO,
        output_schema="candidate-portfolio/v1",
    )
    resolver._contracts.values["parent"] = consumer
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="INPUT_SCOPE_MISMATCH"):
        await resolver.resolve(
            root_trace_id="root",
            script_build_id=7,
            task_id="parent",
            attempt_id=attempt.attempt_id,
            contract=consumer,
            input_snapshot_id="11",
        )


@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_explicit_input_is_revalidated_against_consumer_scope() -> None:
    resolver, ledger, attempt = _closed_fixture()
    child_ref = ledger.attempts["attempt-child"].submission.artifact_refs[0]
    ledger.tasks["child"].parent_task_id = "root-task"
    ledger.tasks["parent"].child_task_ids = []
    ledger.attempts[attempt.attempt_id] = replace(
        attempt,
        accepted_child_decision_ids=(),
    )
    consumer = replace(
        _contract(),
        scope_ref="script-build://scopes/ending",
        input_decision_refs=(
            AcceptedDecisionRef(
                "decision-child",
                child_ref,
                SCOPE,
                ScriptTaskKind.PARAGRAPH,
            ),
        ),
    )
    resolver._contracts.values["parent"] = consumer

    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="INPUT_SCOPE_MISMATCH"):
        await resolver.resolve(
            root_trace_id="root",
            script_build_id=7,
            task_id="parent",
            attempt_id=attempt.attempt_id,
            contract=consumer,
            input_snapshot_id="11",
        )


@pytest.mark.asyncio
@pytest.mark.parametrize("mutation", ["verdict", "snapshot", "digest", "not-current"])
async def test_accepted_input_rejects_broken_causal_edges(mutation: str) -> None:
    resolver, ledger, attempt = _closed_fixture()
    if mutation == "verdict":
        ledger.validations["validation-child"].verdict = ValidationVerdict.FAILED
    elif mutation == "snapshot":
        ledger.validations["validation-child"].snapshot_id = "other"
    elif mutation == "digest":
        resolver._artifacts.version = replace(
            resolver._artifacts.version, canonical_sha256="sha256:" + "b" * 64
        )
    else:
        ledger.tasks["child"].decision_ids.append("other-decision")
    with pytest.raises((PhaseTwoInputError, AssertionError)):
        await resolver.resolve(
            root_trace_id="root",
            script_build_id=7,
            task_id="parent",
            attempt_id=attempt.attempt_id,
            contract=_contract(),
            input_snapshot_id="11",
        )


def test_active_frontier_replacement_cycle_scope_and_write_conflicts() -> None:
    ref1 = ArtifactRef("script-build://artifact-versions/1", "paragraph", "1", DIGEST)
    ref2 = ArtifactRef("script-build://artifact-versions/2", "paragraph", "2", DIGEST)
    bundle = AcceptedInputBundleV1(
        inputs=(
            AcceptedInput("d1", ref1, ScriptTaskKind.PARAGRAPH, SCOPE, "explicit"),
            AcceptedInput("d2", ref2, ScriptTaskKind.PARAGRAPH, SCOPE, "explicit"),
        ),
        input_closure_digest=DIGEST,
    )
    frontier = ActiveFrontierResolver()
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="WRITE_SCOPE_CONFLICT"):
        frontier.resolve(bundle, contracts_by_decision={"d1": _contract(), "d2": _contract()})

    active = frontier.resolve(
        bundle,
        contracts_by_decision={
            "d1": _contract(),
            "d2": _contract(supersedes=("d1",)),
        },
    )
    assert [item.decision_id for item in active] == ["d2"]

    exact_base_patch = replace(_contract(), base_artifact_ref=ref1)
    active = frontier.resolve(
        bundle,
        contracts_by_decision={"d1": _contract(), "d2": exact_base_patch},
    )
    assert [item.decision_id for item in active] == ["d1", "d2"]

    stale_base_patch = replace(
        _contract(),
        base_artifact_ref=replace(ref1, digest="sha256:" + "b" * 64),
    )
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="WRITE_SCOPE_CONFLICT"):
        frontier.resolve(
            bundle,
            contracts_by_decision={"d1": _contract(), "d2": stale_base_patch},
        )

    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="SUPERSESSION_CYCLE"):
        frontier.resolve(
            bundle,
            contracts_by_decision={
                "d1": _contract(supersedes=("d2",)),
                "d2": _contract(supersedes=("d1",)),
            },
        )
    incompatible = AcceptedInputBundleV1(
        inputs=(
            bundle.inputs[0],
            replace(bundle.inputs[1], scope_ref="script-build://scopes/ending"),
        ),
        input_closure_digest=DIGEST,
    )
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="SUPERSESSION_SCOPE_MISMATCH"):
        frontier.resolve(
            incompatible,
            contracts_by_decision={
                "d1": _contract(),
                "d2": _contract(scope="script-build://scopes/ending", supersedes=("d1",)),
            },
        )


def test_stale_base_revision_fails_closed() -> None:
    artifact = replace(_paragraph_artifact(), canonical_sha256=DIGEST)
    version = ArtifactVersion(
        1,
        7,
        "child",
        "attempt-child",
        1,
        ArtifactKind.PARAGRAPH,
        DIGEST,
        ArtifactState.FROZEN,
        artifact,
        datetime.now(UTC),
        datetime.now(UTC),
    )
    lineage = replace(
        artifact.lineage,
        base_artifact_ref="script-build://artifact-versions/1",
        base_artifact_digest=DIGEST,
        base_revision=1,
    )
    ActiveFrontierResolver.verify_base(lineage=lineage, base=version)
    with pytest.raises(PhaseTwoInputError, match="STALE_BASE_REVISION"):
        ActiveFrontierResolver.verify_base(
            lineage=lineage, base=replace(version, artifact_version_id=2)
        )


def test_four_validation_layers_defects_and_placeholder_preflight() -> None:
    assert validation_layer("paragraph") == "local"
    assert validation_layer("compare") == "compare"
    assert validation_layer("compose") == "global"
    assert validation_layer("candidate-portfolio") == "governance"
    assert (
        ScriptBuildValidationPolicy()
        .plan(
            SimpleNamespace(task=_task("t", parent=None, kind="compose", status=TaskStatus.RUNNING))
        )
        .validator_preset
        == "script_candidate_validator"
    )

    payload = {
        "defect_code": "REALIZATION_PLACEHOLDER",
        "criterion_id": "closed",
        "scope_ref": SCOPE,
        "observed_excerpt": "TODO",
        "evidence_refs": ["script-build://artifact-versions/1"],
        "severity": "hard",
        "invalidated_inputs": ["decision-child"],
        "recommended_action_class": "replace",
    }
    with pytest.raises(Exception, match="passed validation"):
        validate_phase_two_defects(
            [payload],
            criterion_ids={"closed"},
            allowed_evidence_refs={"script-build://artifact-versions/1"},
            passed=True,
        )
    defects = validate_phase_two_defects(
        [payload],
        criterion_ids={"closed"},
        allowed_evidence_refs={"script-build://artifact-versions/1"},
        passed=False,
    )
    assert defects[0].blocks_acceptance
    assert precheck_business_artifact(_paragraph_artifact(text="TODO: later")) == (
        "artifact.paragraphs[0].description",
    )
    assert precheck_business_artifact(_paragraph_artifact(text="此处描述其存在")) == (
        "artifact.paragraphs[0].description",
    )


def test_defect_rejects_unknown_criterion_evidence_and_unbounded_excerpt() -> None:
    base = {
        "defect_code": "X",
        "criterion_id": "closed",
        "scope_ref": SCOPE,
        "observed_excerpt": "x",
        "evidence_refs": [],
        "severity": "warning",
        "invalidated_inputs": [],
        "recommended_action_class": "repair",
    }
    with pytest.raises(Exception, match="outside the frozen contract"):
        validate_phase_two_defects(
            [{**base, "criterion_id": "other"}],
            criterion_ids={"closed"},
            allowed_evidence_refs=set(),
            passed=False,
        )
    with pytest.raises(Exception, match="500 characters"):
        validate_phase_two_defects(
            [{**base, "observed_excerpt": "x" * 501}],
            criterion_ids={"closed"},
            allowed_evidence_refs=set(),
            passed=False,
        )


def test_bundle_digest_changes_when_source_or_order_changes() -> None:
    first = canonical_sha256(["a", "b"]).wire
    second = canonical_sha256(["b", "a"]).wire
    assert first != second


def _snapshot_sha(value: dict[str, object]) -> str:
    canonical = json.dumps(value, ensure_ascii=False, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"))
    return hashlib.sha256(canonical.encode()).hexdigest()